Staff names and roles have not yet been verified from the company’s official website.
Workforce
Company-wide headcount
Not yet publicly verified
Indiana headcount
Not yet publicly verified
Company-wide, Indiana, local and parent figures are shown separately. Reporting dates may be older than the date checked. Unavailable figures remain unverified.
Business overview
Brotherhood Mutual Insurance Company describes itself as a national insurer dedicated exclusively to serving Christian ministries, including churches, schools, colleges, camps and mission organizations. Its stated mission is to advance the Kingdom by serving the Church. Source ↗
Products & services
The company offers ministry-focused insurance options that include property, liability, auto, workers’ compensation and accident coverage. It also provides payroll, an HR platform and employee-benefit solutions through Brotherhood Works. Source ↗
Customers & markets
Brotherhood Mutual identifies Christian churches, schools, colleges, camps and mission organizations as the groups it serves. Its website also says it has more than 67,000 ministries served. Source ↗
Company background
Brotherhood Mutual’s About Us page dates its history to 1917, describing the company as having borne one another’s burdens since that year. Source ↗
Indiana connection
The company’s website lists its address as 6400 Brotherhood Way in Fort Wayne, Indiana, and identifies Brotherhood Mutual Insurance Company as an Indiana stock insurance company. Source ↗
Summarized from the company’s official website. Information checked October 19, 2026.
Brotherhood Mutual Insurance Company is reminding churches and related ministries to review payroll practices and strengthen internal controls to avoid financial, legal, and reputational consequences, the company said. Brotherhood Works director Bryan Stine advised ministries to document responsibilities, review procedures, and seek qualified guidance. The company also noted available payroll and HR services through Brotherhood Works, which serves 7,000+ ministries, and emphasized payroll as a risk management issue for ministries.
Brotherhood Mutual issued guidance urging ministry leaders to take a thoughtful, proactive approach to using generative AI, highlighting both opportunities and risks. The company presented four key considerations—credibility and accuracy, potential bias, copyright risks, and data security/privacy—and recommended human oversight, cross-checking sources, stress-testing prompts, using plagiarism detection, avoiding confidential inputs to public tools, and considering enterprise-level secure solutions when AI is central to operations.
