OPINION | Indiana should show what its tax incentives deliver
A new round of federal Opportunity Zones begins Jan. 1. Indiana should tell residents what it expects from the incentives and how it will measure the results.

A new round of federal Opportunity Zones begins Jan. 1. Indiana should tell residents what it expects from the incentives and how it will measure the results.
An Indianapolis shop owner can get a tax deduction for buying qualifying equipment. An investor can defer some capital gains by investing through a qualifying fund. A worker deciding whether to start a business might see those breaks and wonder why the tax code treats the same dollar differently depending on how it’s earned or spent.
That is a fair question. Tax incentives can make it cheaper to invest or hire. Their value to the public depends on what happens after someone claims the break.
What the rules encourage
The federal tax law enacted July 4, 2025, made permanent a 100% first-year depreciation allowance for eligible property acquired after Jan. 19, 2025, once it is put to use. It also made permanent the Section 199A deduction, which lets eligible owners deduct up to 20% of qualified business income, subject to limits. Regular wages from employment generally fall outside that deduction.
Indiana’s Economic Development for a Growing Economy credit, or EDGE, can reward job creation. For a job-creation award, the state calculates the refundable credit as a share of the additional Indiana income tax withholding it expects the new jobs to generate. The amount a company earns depends on its documented performance.
A separate federal program gives qualifying investors capital-gains tax benefits through Opportunity Funds. On Nov. 5, Treasury certified all 126 tracts Indiana nominated for the new round. The IRS list includes 29 in Marion County. The designations take effect Jan. 1, 2027, and last 10 years.
What a deduction is worth
A business can generally deduct ordinary and necessary expenses when it figures its taxable profit. A dollar of deductible spending reduces taxable income by a dollar. The tax savings are only a fraction of the expense, and personal living costs generally stay personal.
Employees can benefit from deductions, too. The federal standard deduction for married couples filing jointly is $32,200 for tax year 2026. Through 2028, eligible workers can also deduct the premium portion of qualifying overtime required by federal law, up to $12,500 annually or $25,000 on a joint return, with income limits. For people who become self-employed, Social Security and Medicare generally come out of their own business earnings, though they can generally deduct the employer-equivalent portion of self-employment tax when figuring federal adjusted gross income.
Indiana’s Department of Revenue lists a 2.95% individual income tax rate in 2026 and 2.90% in 2027. County income taxes can also apply. How much income reaches the individual return depends on the type of income and the applicable state adjustments.
What tax rates measure
A tax return records the income that the law requires someone to report. A stock portfolio can also grow in value while its owner continues to hold the shares. Studies of the tax burden at the top get different answers depending on how they count that growth and which taxes they include.
Economist Danny Yagan estimated that the wealthiest 400 U.S. families paid an average federal individual income tax rate of 9.6% from 1992 through 2020 when measured against a broad income estimate that included changes in wealth, before adjusting for inflation. That calculation covers one category of tax.
A 2025 National Bureau of Economic Research working paper by Akcan Balkir, Emmanuel Saez, Yagan and Gabriel Zucman used a different measure of income that includes owners’ shares of business profits. Counting taxes at all levels of government, the authors estimated an effective rate of about 24% for roughly the 400 wealthiest tax units in 2018–20 and about 30% for the population as a whole. These are estimates that depend on how the researchers assign taxes and define income.
That distinction matters to the Indianapolis worker weighing a side business. A deduction might change whether an equipment purchase makes sense. It tells you little about how taxes add up for someone who owns a large share of a company.
What Indiana should measure
Indiana’s September economic update said 69 businesses had committed to creating 5,385 jobs so far in 2026. EDGE’s certification process gives the state a way to check payroll as individual projects progress. Residents should be able to see how many promised jobs materialized, what wages those jobs paid and how much the state gave up in revenue.
The same questions apply in the new Opportunity Zones. Treasury researchers track how much capital has gone into the earlier round. In Marion County, residents also need to know which projects got built, what changed for people already living there and how much of the investment would have happened anyway.
The new designations give Indianapolis a chance to say what success would look like before the investments arrive. Publish the starting numbers, track them over time and tell residents what the tax break bought.
Report a correction · Editorial standards · Our source directory
Opinion: recommendations and judgments are those of the BusinessIndy Editorial Desk.
Related coverage
- AEP, Amazon and X‑energy to study 960 MW Xe‑100 SMR at Sullivan County brownfield
- Citizenship Is the Common Ground Business Needs
- Election Day should be a national holiday


Reader discussion
Join the discussion. Every comment is checked before publication. Community rules and appeals