First Internet shareholder proposes independent review of a possible sale
A First Internet Bancorp shareholder has asked the Fishers-based company’s independent directors to evaluate whether the bank holding company should be sold.

A First Internet Bancorp shareholder has asked the Fishers-based company’s independent directors to evaluate whether the bank holding company should be sold.
John C. Lame submitted the request through a shareholder proposal intended for First Internet’s 2027 annual meeting, according to an exhibit filed with the Securities and Exchange Commission on Nov. 13.
The proposal asks the independent directors to hire an investment bank with community-bank merger experience and report the review’s results to shareholders by Dec. 31, 2027. It defines a qualifying sale as a transaction in which current First Internet shareholders would own less than half of the combined company.
The request does not require First Internet to sell itself, and the filing does not show that the board has started a strategic review or approved a transaction. First Internet Bancorp is the parent of First Internet Bank and is headquartered in Fishers.
Filings with the Securities and Exchange Commission show Lame delivered a Nov. 13 letter and an accompanying PowerPoint to Lead Independent Director John K. Keach Jr., and that a Rule 14a-8 proposal letter the same day was addressed to President and COO Nicole S. Lorch and sent by Federal Express and email, according to the exhibits filed with the SEC.
The proposal further specifies that the independent directors should promptly retain an investment bank experienced in community-bank mergers and acquisitions that has not advised First Internet in the past three years and that will report only to the independent directors; the proposal reiterates it requests only a review and a report, not a sale. Lame’s Schedule 13D filing also notes the company’s Sept. 10, 2025 announcement that a planned sale of up to $869 million of single-tenant lease loans closed at $836.9 million with a pre-tax loss of $37.8 million.
Report a correction · Editorial standards · Our source directory
BusinessIndy examines this development and its implications for Indiana businesses and communities using the linked sources.
SOURCE STATUS: One-source report; independent confirmation pending.
Sources
- U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, Schedule 13D/A: Shareholder asks First Internet Bancorp to examine a possible sale ↗
- Proposal: Recommending an Independent Review of a Sale of the Company ↗
A sourced news brief; no independent staff reporting is implied. Prepared with AI assistance; source-dependent claims remain attributed in the article.
Related coverage
- Kirkwood Avenue parking will be restricted after Saturday’s IU–USC game
- Amazon marks a construction milestone for $7 billion Jasper County campus
- Carmel insurer CNO renews shareholder rights plan tied to tax losses


Reader discussion
Join the discussion. Every comment is checked before publication. Community rules and appeals