Family alleges patient-safety lapse at IU Health Methodist after Indianapolis man with dementia goes missing
A family search is underway for 53-year-old Gary Roberts II, last seen about 2:00 a.m. on 2026-09-04 at IU Health Methodist Hospital in Indianapolis; his sister says he requires dialysis three times a week, suffers severe dementia, and that hospital staff delayed notifying family and issued an inaccurate Silver Alert.

Gary Roberts II, 53, was last seen at approximately 2:00 a.m. on 2026-09-04 inside a locked medical unit at IU Health Methodist Hospital in Indianapolis. The article describes him as about 6 ft tall, 178 lbs, with sandy brown hair, blue eyes, a beard and a dragon tattoo; he was wearing a multicolored hospital gown, blue scrub pants and blue-and-white shoes.
His sister and legal guardian, Diana, told reporters Gary requires dialysis three times a week and suffers severe dementia, a cognitive learning disability and a heart condition. She alleges hospital staff did not notify her of his disappearance until about 4:00 a.m., and that the initial Silver Alert misidentified his disappearance location and some physical details; the search is ongoing and the article lists IU Health Department of Public Safety at (317) 962-8000 or 911 for tips.
Report a correction · Editorial standards · Our source directory
BusinessIndy examines this development and its implications for Indiana businesses and communities using the linked sources.
Continued verification is in progress.
Sources
Source date recorded as September 17, 2026 at 8:49 AM EDT. A sourced news brief; no independent staff reporting is implied. Prepared with AI assistance; source-dependent claims remain attributed in the article.
Related coverage
- IU Health’s Mosaic Center to add monthly orientations at 1776 N. Meridian St. to connect Indianapolis residents to healthcare jobs
- Indiana awards $13.1M GROW grant to Region 7 to expand rural healthcare services and workforce
- Indianapolis-based Eli Lilly reports Foundayo tied to modeled cuts in 10‑year diabetes and cardiovascular risk
Reader discussion
Join the discussion. Every comment is checked before publication. Community rules and appeals