Colts lose in overtime at Chiefs after Harrison Butker’s 40-yard field goal
The Colts fell to the Kansas City Chiefs in overtime at Arrowhead Stadium when Chiefs kicker Harrison Butker converted a 40-yard field goal as time expired, handing Indianapolis a loss that left the team 0-2, according to the Colts’ game report.

Indianapolis dropped a Week 2 overtime decision at Arrowhead Stadium after Chiefs kicker Harrison Butker’s 40-yard field goal as time expired in overtime. The Colts carried a 20-17 halftime lead highlighted by a Jonathan Taylor rushing touchdown and early scoring connection from Daniel Jones to tight end Tyler Warren. Indy also lost wide receiver Alec Pierce to a first-quarter heel injury and entered the game without Ashton Dulin (ankle).
Kansas City rallied in the second half through big plays from Patrick Mahomes — including a long completion to Tyquan Thornton and a touchdown to Jalen Royals — and converted late to force overtime. In overtime both teams traded short field goals before the Chiefs regained possession and finished the comeback with Butker’s game-winner; the Colts also tied the game at 30 on a Spencer Shrader 38-yard field goal earlier in overtime, per the team report.
Report a correction · Editorial standards · Our source directory
BusinessIndy examines this development and its implications for Indiana businesses and communities using the linked sources.
Continued verification is in progress.
Sources
A sourced news brief; no independent staff reporting is implied. Prepared with AI assistance; source-dependent claims remain attributed in the article.
Related coverage
- Colts long snapper Luke Rhodes named 2026 Salute to Service nominee
- Notre Dame–Miami matchup expected to bring millions to Michiana, ABC57/WSBT reports
- Colts feature highlights Evansville Memorial senior QB Luke Brown’s leadership and big-game moments


Reader discussion
Join the discussion. Every comment is checked before publication. Community rules and appeals